Merry Xmas Stocking

Last year I made a red and white Christmas stockings with "Merry Xmas" knitted on it. It sold pretty quickly in my Etsy shop, the only "Merry Xmas" stocking I sold, I think. I've been making a few more, they're nice for trying out colors, and I've been listing them as I made them. But strangely, the most views are still coming to the old one that was sold, from Pinterest! So I decided to re-knit the red one, of course, it's not exactly the same because that would be boring...

So the 2012-version:



















And the 2013-version:

Merry Xmas knitted Christmas stocking with reindeer

For sale now in my Etsy shop, only one available. If I make it again next year, it will again be different! 
Gigi82Knits








Which one do you prefer?